Yesterday afternoon our neighbour who's going to be painting our house stopped by with paint chips of the original house colours as well as a few other options. We decided to just go with what we already had - although we'll be changing the accent colour because we chose poorly last time.
So the house itself will be Cloud Nine and the accent is Smoked Oyster. They're both a kind of greyish blue. I believe the accent was originally the darker colour on the bottom (Grayling), but it faded so badly we decided to go one lighter this time. It'll be nice to have this done and not have to worry about it for another 12 years!